Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Living in the Florida Keys

Living in the Florida Keys

Everything You Need to Know Before Making Paradise Home

Moving to the Florida Keys is about so much more than buying a house—it’s about embracing an entirely different lifestyle. Whether you’re planning to relocate full-time, purchase a second home, or invest in a vacation property, it’s natural to have questions.

I’ve called the Upper Florida Keys home for over 20 years, and my family has been enjoying life here since 1967. One of my favorite parts of being a Realtor is helping buyers understand what day-to-day life is really like. Below are answers to the questions I’m asked most often. And if you don’t see yours here, I’d love to help.

General Living

Imagine slowing down just enough to enjoy life.

People wave to one another, sunsets become part of your daily routine, and it’s completely normal to stop after work to watch the tarpon feed or take the boat out for an hour. Life here revolves around the water, friends, family, and enjoying the outdoors.

Every island has its own personality, and one of my favorite things is helping clients find the community that feels most like home.

That depends on your lifestyle.

If you travel frequently, Key Largo offers the shortest drive to Miami. Tavernier provides wonderful neighborhoods with a relaxed feel. Islamorada is famous for world-class fishing, incredible restaurants, and luxury waterfront homes. Marathon offers more residential options and a central location, while Key West has a vibrant culture unlike anywhere else.

We’ll talk about your goals before we ever start looking at homes because choosing the right island is just as important as choosing the right house.

It can be, but it depends on your lifestyle.

Insurance, utilities, and housing costs are generally higher than many other parts of Florida, but many residents feel the quality of life more than makes up for it. I’ll help you understand the true cost of ownership before you buy so you can make an informed decision.

Boating

Not at all—but many people eventually decide they want one!

You can enjoy kayaking, paddleboarding, snorkeling, fishing, diving, waterfront dining, and beautiful parks without ever owning a boat.

That said, after living here awhile…don’t be surprised if you start browsing boats.

This is where local knowledge really matters.

Not all waterfront homes offer the same boating experience. We’ll discuss water depth, bridge clearance, dock length, boat lifts, tides, turning basins, ocean versus bay access, and how long it takes to reach open water.

These details can dramatically affect your enjoyment—and your property’s long-term value.

Many waterfront homes include private dockage, but every property is different.

We’ll verify dock permits, lift capacity, seawall condition, and whether your boat fits comfortably before you purchase.

Hurricane Preparedness

Living in paradise means respecting Mother Nature.

Residents prepare well before hurricane season begins by reviewing insurance, maintaining shutters or impact windows, trimming landscaping, and having a plan.

The good news is that today’s building codes have made newer homes much stronger than many people realize.

Sometimes.

Evacuation decisions are made by local officials depending on the projected storm.

Having lived here for many years, I’ve experienced the process firsthand and I’m always happy to explain how it works to buyers moving from out of state.

Insurance

Because we live on islands surrounded by water.

Most homeowners carry several different types of insurance, including homeowners, wind, flood (when required), and sometimes additional coverage depending on the property.

I introduce my buyers to trusted local insurance professionals early in the process so there are no surprises.

Not always.

Whether flood insurance is required depends on your lender, flood zone, elevation, and other factors.

We’ll determine what’s required before you’re under contract, not afterward.

Fishing & Outdoor Life

Honestly…it’s even better.

Whether you’re into offshore fishing, backcountry adventures, reef fishing, lobster season, or simply catching dinner after work, there’s always something in season.

One of the best parts of living here is that world-class fishing isn’t something you save for vacation—it’s your backyard.

The list is long.

Residents enjoy diving, snorkeling, paddleboarding, kayaking through mangrove trails, biking, beach days, pickleball, tennis, eco-tours, sunset cruises, bird watching, and exploring our incredible marine environments.

If you enjoy being outside, you’ll probably never run out of things to do.

Schools

Yes.

The Keys offer public, charter, and private school options depending on where you live.

Families often choose neighborhoods based on commute times and school preferences, and I’m always happy to help explain the different communities and what may fit your family’s needs.

Healthcare

The Florida Keys have hospitals, urgent care centers, specialists, and many primary care providers throughout the island chain.

For highly specialized medical care, many residents travel to the Miami area, which is one reason some buyers prefer the Upper Keys.

This is an important conversation, especially for retirees, and I’m happy to share local resources.

Pets

Very much so.

You’ll find dog-friendly parks, outdoor restaurants, walking paths, pet services, beaches (where permitted), and plenty of neighbors who love animals just as much as you do.

As a fellow dog lover myself, I know how important it is to find a home that’s perfect for every member of the family—including the four-legged ones.

Utilities

Some are.

Electricity, internet, water, sewer, and waste collection vary depending on where you live.

Certain islands also have different internet providers or utility districts.

I’ll help connect you with local providers so setting up your new home is as easy as possible

Homesteading

Absolutely, if the property becomes your permanent Florida residence and you qualify under Florida law.

Many full-time residents benefit from valuable property tax savings through the Homestead Exemption.

I’ll walk you through the timeline and point you toward the appropriate county resources after closing.

Flood Zones

Not necessarily.

Nearly every community in the Keys has some relationship to flood maps simply because we’re islands.

What’s important is understanding elevation, construction, insurance costs, and how those factors affect your ownership experience.

I’ll help you understand the differences so you can make an informed decision.

Lifestyle

How quickly they slow down. And how tight nit the community it. Everyone is willing to help.

The traffic lights disappear, sunsets become nightly entertainment, and people spend more time outdoors than indoors.

Many buyers tell me they wish they’d made the move years earlier.

That’s easy.

It’s the people. The Sunrises. And the Smiles I help create.

Yes, we have beautiful water, amazing fishing, incredible diving, and breathtaking sunsets—but what truly makes the Keys special is the sense of community. Neighbors become friends, local businesses know your name, and there’s always someone willing to lend a hand after a storm or celebrate with you on a perfect day out on the water.

Helping people discover that lifestyle (or who are in need) is one of the reasons I love what I do

Still Have Questions?

Moving to the Florida Keys is exciting, but it also comes with plenty of questions. Whether you’re wondering about waterfront neighborhoods, boating, schools, insurance, fishing, vacation rentals, or simply what life is really like here, I’m always happy to help.

I believe buying a home should feel exciting—not overwhelming. My goal is to provide honest advice, local insight, and the kind of personalized service that continues long after closing. If you’re thinking about making the Florida Keys your home, I’d love to be your local resource every step of the way.

Work With an Expert in Your Area

Work with Krissy Carnahan for personalized guidance, expert negotiation, and local knowledge to help you buy or sell with confidence. Krissy delivers exceptional service and local expertise throughout the Florida Keys.

Follow Me on Instagram